I've been wanting to post a comment about this subject for quite a long time. The only reason I haven't yet, is because I fear I will disprove the very point I'm trying to make. Maybe if I keep it short I can get away with it.
Those who read my rants reguarly have no doubt noticed that I often refer to myself as "Your humble friend and uneducated blogger." Most of you have chosen to ignore that phrase in your comments, but ER once asked me why I say that.
I answered him at the time but here is the long answer to that query:
First, I borrowed the phrase from Anthony Burgess's novel, "
A Clockwork Orange". Alex, as the first person main character, referred to himself as "
your humble friend and narrator". I altered it to present myself more accurately.
Second, I was not fortunate enough to finish college, thus, I am uneducated. The reason that I continue to use that phrase is because I seek to disprove the myth that education is synonymous with intelligence.
When I was in Junior High School (Known as Middle School these days), we were not allowed to know the scores of that test we all take in the 8th grade. That one that tells the administrators our IQ. So, we weren't told what our IQ was. I still don't know what mine is. Was. Whatever. However, one teacher, during a conference, let it slip that I had the second highest IQ in the school, and she told me who had the highest. The next year that kid committed suicide.
So many people seem to be under the mistaken impression that one cannot be intelligent without having letters after their name. I myself have fallen into that trap. In a post I made some time back, I ridiculed same celiberals for calling President Bush stupid while they themselves possessed no more than a high school education. So, yes, I have done the same thing.
I consider myself to be highly intelligent. I am not just bragging. My entire family is highly intelligent. My mother, at 85 years old, is still sharp as ever, and she is a mathematical genius. Once, after purchasing a brand new calculator, I attempted to demonstrate how fast it was. My sister vocalized a math problem ,and while I was still punching the numbers in on the keypad, my mother gave the answer. She beat the calculator!
My brother is a musical virtuoso. He can pick up any musical instrument and be playing it like an expert in minutes, even if he never played it before. He is the only one of my brothers that we know for sure is an actual genius. The others may be, I just don't know it for a fact.
None of my family had to go to college to be intelligent. They already were, they just chose to go to college also. I actually did go to college long enough to be considered a bona fide alumnus at Wichita State University, but I didn't finish. Thus, I am uneducated.
Anyway, this same attitude is part of the reason why Harriet Miers is being judged as not qualified by many conservatives. Some have gone so far as to denigrate her because the school she received her law degree from was not an "accepted" Ivy league school. That is patently absurd. She has a law degree. What makes anyone think that because it is not from Harvard, Yale, Princeton, or Dartmouth, that it is somehow not adequate? And who can say she isn't more intelligent and better at comprehending the language of the Constitution than those who have degrees from those above named institutions? It is quite possible, in my opinion, that she may not need to have an education at all to be qualified to interpret the Constitution.
I don't have a law degree, but I once represented myself in a lawsuit filed against me by a hospital who wanted to charge me for services they didn't render. I cross examined the witnesses, and concluded my case with a summation that would have made Clarence Darrow proud. I lost the case against the corporate lawyers chiefly because I waited until they brought suit against me to defend myself. In other words, I had never previously objected to the charges, I had simply ignored the bills.
The witnesses I had questioned admitted to me afterwards that I made them nervous because they had no answers to my questions. An opposing lawyer told me afterwards that I did a remarkable job of presenting my case, and if I had been a lawyer, with a law degree, I might possibly have won.
I don't meant to insinuate that a college education is not important. It most certainly is. I know that if I had finished school I would be better off financially than I am now. I know it. I have seen it time and time again that someone who has an education gets preferential treatment, as far as careers, over those who don't. One doesn't even have to have a degree in the particular field in which they are employed to get that job.
One of my brothers has a degree in Graphic Arts, and has a successful career at Boeing Aircraft in a completely unrelated field, but he wouldn't have got that job if he didn't have a degree. Any degree, it would seem, will do. I continually try to pound that message into my son's noggin.
I also don't mean to say that someone who has a degree isn't intelligent. I maintain that one has to have better than average intelligence just to get through college. But education is not a measure of intelligence.
There have been throughout history, literally thousands of great minds who never had a formal education at all. I don't know if Einstein ever received a degree in anything but I know it is well known that he once flunked math.
I have to say, I find it insulting when so-called educated people discount the opinions of those who don't have degrees because of a delusional impression that a lack of education signifies a lack of intelligent thought.
I once worked with a lady who had an degree in education. She wasn't employed at the time as a teacher although she had a valid teaching certificate. She did do substitute teaching when called. But the job she had in my office was as a telemarketer. She had to use multiple lines, with six clearly marked buttons, showing which lines were local and which lines were watts lines. She couldn't grasp the concept.
By the same token I know people who have great intelligence who have never attended college at all.
My father was promoted to the position of engineer at Boeing Military Aircraft because of the sheer amount of knowledge about the product they manufactured. He had no formal training or education as an engineer.
He did have a degree in English.
He once designed an airplane, just for fun, and threw the completed drawing in the trash because he didn't believe that Boeing would even consider the drastic departure from the typical aircraft design of the day.
His design had a remarkable resemblance to an F-16 fighter. This was years before the F-16 was introduced. In fact, jet engines were a brand new innovation at the time.
Anyway, I have made this rant way too long, against my better judgment. So I will conclude it with this statement:
Intelligence and education are not the same thing.